Standing Apart: How Independent Eye Care is Winning in the Age of Big Retail

Corporate chains and online retailers may offer convenience, but private practice eye care is doubling down on what patients truly value – care, connection and community. 

 From personalized service and staff training to specialty care and strong branding, independent practices are leaning into their strengths and showing patients why care still matters – and why it cannot be commoditized. 

 The Big Retail-Proof Experience 

While online retailers promise low-cost convenience, they often fall short in the critical area of trust. Private practice is winning by creating experiences that cannot be duplicated through an app or in a big-box setting.

 “As a practice owner, I am able to provide a full scope of optometry services while offering a personalized experience for my patients,” said Kennard Herring, OD, owner of Nostalgic Eye Care in Philadelphia, PA. “That includes offering treatment beyond the scope of eye exams and providing expert recommendations for frames and lenses based on my patients’ needs. It’s all about building strong bonds that fortify a patient’s trust.” 

That trust is reinforced at every step of the in-office journey – from the initial phone call to personalized frame styling in the optical. PECAA Max members are enhancing this experience with the support of PECAA’s Business Advisory team, which offers expertise in all aspects of practice management, from optical strategy to practice operations, billing and coding, marketing and more. Resources like the Frame Focus: Inside the Brand webinar series help practices create a cohesive, high-value patient experience that drives both loyalty and revenue.

 The Power of Storytelling & Brand 

Today, a brand is more than a logo—it’s your voice, values and story. For some practices, that brand story is deeply tied to their local roots.  

 “Our small town is all about ‘Supporting Local.’ We make it a point to purchase from our local small business friends,” said Emily Ridge, OD, owner of Elite Eyecare in Hernando, MS. “That has also helped us build relationships and increase our patient base!” 

Ridge further elaborated that partnering with local organizations like the chamber of commerce and engaging in community events allows you to educate prospective patients while gaining referrals, new patients and new friends.

 Another way to share your practice’s “why” is through storytelling. Sharing your narrative is a way to communicate, educate and connect with others by making information more relatable and memorable.  

“I share my life experiences with my patients, which allows them to connect with me as a person, not just a provider,” said Dr. Herring. “Without that communication, you cannot build trust – it helps your patient learn about you on a deeper level.” 

PECAA Max members can leverage marketing expertise through the Business Advisory team to bring these stories to life – refining websites, boosting social media presence and aligning digital and in-office messaging for a consistent, memorable patient experience.

 Staff as the Face of Your Brand 

While most practice owners understand the value of branding, some overlook their most powerful brand asset—their team. From the front desk to the optical, every patient interaction shapes perception and loyalty.

 “I believe that it’s my responsibility to set the tone and develop and sustain the culture for our office. I lead by example and model the behavior I want my staff to exude,” said Dr. Herring. “In addition, we hold regular office meetings and have open dialogue about the treatment of our patients to ensure we’re all aligned with our practice mission of providing comprehensive, competent, patient-centered vision care.” 

 Practices are investing in training beyond technical skills to communication, empathy and education. PECAA Max members have access to a robust portfolio of staff development resources, including onboarding toolkits and certification programs in office management, billing and coding and optical management. Many are included with membership or available at exclusive discounts. 

 Specialties That Help You Stand Out 

In addition to optimizing the patient experience and branding, independent practices are winning by leaning into services big-box and online models simply can’t offer – like dry eye treatment, myopia control, vision therapy and aesthetics.  

 “That patient-centered approach comes through in every specialty offering,” Dr. Ridge explained. “Our patients aren’t just coming in for an eye exam; they’re coming in so we can help them read their Bible or other text easier, improve their  tennis game or assist them with meeting their day-to-day visual needs as comfortably as possible. Offering comprehensive specialty vision services shows your commitment to your patients, and in turn, they will be loyal to your practice for years to come.” 

 These specialties don’t just diversify revenue streams – they deepen patient loyalty and drive referrals. Programs like PECAA Dry Eye Partners and 90 Days to Dry Eye give members a clear roadmap to implement advanced care with confidence, including protocols, staff training, marketing templates and peer support. 

 When practices invest in specialty services, they become more than a provider – they become a trusted partner in their patients’ long-term health. 

 The Private Practice Edge 

At a glance, the corporate model might seem intimidating. But private practice owners know their competitive edge. Patients crave comprehensive  care, clarity and connection – and independent eye care is uniquely positioned to deliver all three. 

 Private practices are winning by leading with empathy, backed by business strategy. Through PECAA resources like business advisory services, specialty programs such as PECAA Dry Eye Partners, 90 Days to Dry Eye and training like the Optometric Business Academy and Launch to Legacy: PECAA’s Recipe for Successand so much more, PECAA Max members are building practices that are as strong behind the scenes as they are in the exam room.